Daily Oil Fundamentals

Liberation Day 2026

They say that victory has a million fathers, but defeat is an orphan. In Donald Trump’s dictionary, the same wisdom reads as follows: victory has one father, me, but defeat has a million others, anybody but me. Following the catastrophic Republican defeat last week, the underlying causes have been, and no doubt will continue to be, scrutinised. We join the herd. To begin with, it is imperative to point out that the Democrats did not win last week’s midterm elections. The Republicans, for reasons discussed below, lost them.

To understand what led to the outright repudiation of the Republican Party last Tuesday, we should start by looking at what propelled the second Trump Administration back into the White House two years ago. We see three major reasons.

First, liberal democracy, in its current, or rather recent, state, had been failing the voter. Its most significant shortcoming is, ironically, particularly relevant given the incumbent US President’s efforts to act as an unconstrained ruler: it lies in the unnecessarily rigid checks on executive power. While the fundamental idea behind the separation of the three branches of government – the legislative, the executive and the judiciary – is to divide power so that no single person or institution can exercise total control, the discretionary powers of the executive branch have been gradually eroded. This often leads to political gridlock, an inability to respond to crises or make decisions and, consequently, general frustration with the establishment.

Second, there is the self-interest of the tech companies running social media platforms. Their sole objective is to generate engagement, and the most effective way of achieving this is to encourage extremism. The ubiquitous use of the internet has undermined the role of institutions that were previously able to filter misinformation and disinformation. An alternative reality has emerged, resulting in increasingly polarised societies and culminating in violent protests by supporters of extremism on both sides of the political spectrum. Donald Trump shrewdly exploited social media to his advantage.

Finally, the US President was much better prepared to enter the White House in 2025 than he had been in 2021. His first election victory probably took him more by surprise than it did his opponent, Hillary Clinton. This lack of preparation forced him to rely on government officials and cabinet members for whom the rule of law was the gold standard of governance, effectively limiting the President’s authority. He made no such mistake four years later, when the most important, and possibly the only, requirement was unconditional loyalty, preferably played out in public, whether from within the Administration or from corporate America.

These three factors, together with his populist campaign pledges, secured Mr Trump an unquestionable victory in 2024. Not only did he win the presidential election fair and square, but he also secured the popular vote. This undeniable legitimacy boosted his confidence, which, in hindsight, sowed the seeds of his political annihilation. His promises of ‘no more war’ and $2-a-gallon gasoline were wilfully ignored, while he remained reluctant to acknowledge the growing discontent. Even measures that initially met with voters’ approval, such as his crackdown on illegal immigration, spectacularly backfired because of their heavy-handed implementation.

His policy decisions have often drawn comparisons with fascism – just think of the treatment of undocumented immigrants. This parallel is fundamentally misplaced. While many of his actions ticked the boxes of Umberto Eco’s 1995 essay on ‘Ur-Fascism’ (disagreement is treason), the fascist’s highest human purpose is war, which relies on a bureaucratic state. Mr Trump, as so eloquently explored in another essay by historian Thomas Weber, does not believe in the state or society; he wants to demolish them. We still remember the gutting of the government by a very rich, but unelected business leader in early 2025. He believes in the purest and cruellest form of capitalism, without rules or regulation. His highest human purpose is self-enrichment, which he pursues brazenly and even proudly, because it comes naturally to him. For him, the essay concludes, government is a family business.

His personal pride, dare we say ego, has markedly shaped his domestic and foreign policy decisions. The political scientist Francis Fukuyama calls the craving for recognition ‘thymos’. When recognition is forthcoming, one feels pride. When it is not, the response is anger and outrage, which, in the case of the US President, can lead to calling Norway a ‘s..t house’, imposing import duties on Canada or even threatening to invade a NATO member, such as Greenland.

Defining Donald Trump is a complex, perhaps even impossible, task. The purpose of the above exercise was to highlight his mercurial and capricious character. His past actions and the patterns we have observed suggest that another two years of unpredictability lie ahead. The Iranian truce is anything but secure. Houthis claimed responsibility for a weekend attack on Riyadh, although fresh US strikes on Iran do not appear imminent. Russian hostilities towards Ukraine could intensify, as the latest assaults on Ukrainian power stations and on a vessel in the Black Sea strongly insinuate. Inflation could remain elevated. Mr Trump will continue to wield power, possibly more over foreign than domestic policy.

The broader picture is intriguing. For staunch advocates of liberal democracy, the outcome of the midterm elections, particularly in the context of this year’s elections in Hungary, Serbia and Brazil, as well as the UK’s attempted realignment with the EU, is more than welcome. These developments strongly suggest that deviations from the norm, defined as the political centre, whether left or right, have a limited lifespan – 16 years in Hungary’s case and 10 years in the US. Nonetheless, advocates of liberal democracy are acutely aware that the upcoming general elections in France, Spain and Germany could cement the popularity of far-right parties in these countries.

Last Tuesday might go down in US history as ‘Liberation Day 2.0’, but a return to the norm will be a cumbersome yet satisfying process. Although the mills of history grind slowly, the end of history, borrowing a phrase from Friedrich Hegel, might just be in sight once again. And what does this rambling have to do with the core tenet of this note, namely the global economy and the oil balance? Autocracies tend to boast of rapid but short-lived economic prosperity, paved with sabre-rattling and street fights, while liberal democracies quietly ensure long-term economic stability based on social and political equilibrium.

Overnight Pricing

 

09 Nov 2026